So. This was an Ausiello spoiler a few weeks ago:
Question: Your Puck poll was fun and everything, but do you have any actual intel about who he’ll be dating post-Lauren on Glee? —Jen
Ausiello: I’ll say this: In the wake of Zizes, Puck — while revisiting familiar romantic waters from Season 1 — finds a new woman. And that, my friends, is a riddle wrapped in an enigma.
My thoughts - something I tossed around when we recorded Glee Chat this week, but a big segment got cut because we went way off-topic - was that this could possibly be Shelby. The more I think about it, the more I feel legit about it. I think he will become close with her when Shelby tries to bring Quinn into Beth's life.
We know age isn't an issue for Puck, and there is emotional attachment there... either way, I can't wait to see Puck and Beth stuff, because he broke my heart in season 1.